My Sisters History!

THE place for your Sisters-related comments, questions and snippets of Sisters information. For those who do not know, The Sisters of Mercy are a rock'n'roll band. And a pop band. And an industrial groove machine. Or so they say. They make records. Lots of records, apparently. But not in your galaxy. They play concerts. Lots of concerts, actually. But you still cannot see them. So what's it all about, Alfie? This is one of the few tightly-moderated forums on Heartland, so please keep on-topic. All off-topic posts will either be moved or deleted. Chairman Bux is the editor and the editor's decision is final. Danke.
User avatar
Tidal
Gonzoid Amphetamine Filth
Posts: 442
Joined: 06 Mar 2007, 11:50
Location: The Hollow Land

Dear Heartlanders, I have great news for you! In three days, at exactly September 18, 09:46:31, the day that I first learned of The Sisters of Mercy, will be a year ago! Then is the birthday of my musical obsession :)

To celebrate the event and to create a sense of nostalgia, I have created an accurate depiction of the way my Sisters history developed. Feel free to add your own if you still remember it!


How it all began

In the morning of Monday the eighteenth of September 2006, I was downloading a video file about the heroic acts of an fictuous character in an online game. After it was downloaded, I watched it. The creator of it had included for the soundtrack of his movie the song Temple of Love '92, which started a few minutes into the video. When I first heard it it didn't interest me much, it only struck me how low the singer's voice was and that in contrast with the high female voice. But since that wasn't all that unique, it sounded to me like yet another metal song. (yes! TOL sounded like metal when I first heard it :lol: )

But in the following days, me appreciating the video a lot, Temple of Love began to tighten its grasp on me as I began to get intruiged by the song. It somehow interested me. After approximately a week I really liked the song and watched the credits on the end to discover it was by The Sisters of Mercy (which again sounded a bit weird, making me think it was a travesty based act ;D ). I then proceeded to check Youtube for a clip.

After watching the TOL video, I was sold. Although the spinning disc thing and the pentagram and the various images from other vids were a bit weird, the rising moon from the temple hit me hard as the best opening shot of any music+image combination I had ever seen. The pigeon thing and clouds, rocks and cliffs also seemed like a good combination with the music. For the following days I was completely caught up by the song; I have an accurate memory about how I was biking to school every morning mumbling the lyrics over and over again- I was amazed. I wrote Temple of Love down in my booklet of Nr.1 songs ever, which up to then only contained various pop artists and an occasional mild goth or mild rock artist. To this day TOL '92 is still my favourite song ever.

In the days to come I tried to find more about the Sisters- first of all I watched Black Planet, Lucretia, Dominion and This Corrosion, later I found Doctor Jeep, More and 1959. I really liked the vids and Dominion and Lucretia became instant classics to me.

I did a little bit of research on the Sisters' background (but not much..)
I then used my basic downloading tool, Limewire, to try and find some Sisters stuff. From then on, I have downloaded over a hundred files, of which I have the chronological order stored in my PC. I was able to make a list.

I downloaded Temple of Love '92 at 18/10/2006/06:49:21. In those days, I still had a lot of pop songs in my playlists and listened to those, occasionally listening to TOL and watching the vids. From then on I sometimes found a Sisters song and downloaded it, resulting in the following selection of dates:

Temple of Love '92 18/10/2006/06:49:21
Lucretia my Reflection 27/10/2006/09:09:27
Dominion 27/10/2006/09:09:37
(Black Planet(jap version)) 05/11/2006/23:52:52
Marian 01/12/2006/09:46:11
(This Corrosion(short version))01/12/2006/09:53:47
Walk Away 01/12/2006/09:53:59
More 01/12/2006/10:04:00
Vision Thing 01/12/2006/10:08:33
Alice 93 02/12/2006/16:53:05
Burn It Down 02/12/2006/17:02:51
No Time to Cry 02/12/2006/17:03:10
Driven Like the Snow 02/12/2006/17:03:15

For nearly three months, these were the only Sisters songs I knew. I listened to them mixed with the pop songs I had but gradually they began to take over- I began to realise I had found my favourite band. This period influenced me greatly, as all of these songs remind me of those days when I hear them.

Finally my Sisters liking took over and at a certain point I refused to listen to any other music than the Sisters anymore- at that point, the reason was that the pop stuff and the Sisters just don't mix anymore- the Sisters sounded better when listened to without interference.

This period was marked by my liking of TOL first. I did like the rest but it wasn't as good. As I downloaded a bit I then began to like Marian a lot- first I could not hear the vocals because they were too low but later I really loved the music. And lastly after a while I REALLY began to like Driven Like the Snow, which had just been "the quiet song" on my playlist for a long while- until I turned the volume up and discovered what a gem it really was. Driven Like the Snow became the newest Nr.1 song on my list.

After nearly three months of absence of new material, there was the magical February 24 ! That day, I got amazingly lucky on Limewire, which I decided to try again after a long time of not downloading much. That day, I downloaded no less than TWENTY FIVE Sisters songs.

Doctor Jeep 24/02/2007/12:37:03
Valentine 24/02/2007/12:37:28
Under the Gun 24/02/2007/12:37:43
Ribbons 24/02/2007/12:37:52
Something Fast 24/02/2007/12:38:01
Anaconda 24/02/2007/12:39:05
I Was Wrong 24/02/2007/12:39:11
Burn 24/02/2007/12:39:21
Kiss the Carpet(reprise) 24/02/2007/12:39:27
Heartland 24/02/2007/12:39:28
Watch 24/02/2007/12:39:35
Never Land(a fragment) 24/02/2007/12:40:55
Nine While Nine 24/02/2007/12:41:00
Possession 24/02/2007/12:41:07
Some Kind of Stranger 24/02/2007/12:41:17
The Damage Done 24/02/2007/12:41:35
Body Electric 24/02/2007/12:51:02
1959 24/02/2007/12:51:10
1969 24/02/2007/12:51:22
A Rock and a Hard Place 24/02/2007/12:51:26
Adrenochrome 24/02/2007/12:51:32
Floorshow 24/02/2007/12:52:49
Phantom 24/02/2007/12:52:57
Home of the Hitmen 24/02/2007/12:53:27
Garden of Delight 24/02/2007/14:56:17

these songs marked a new period for me, with less commercial-based, musically "full" songs like the popular Alice 93, TOL, Dominion and Lucretia, and more "sober", less rocky songs, more quiet and older. Neither of these became a real hit for me, so at first I used them to listen to while making homework (the memory of Something Fast while learning Chemistry still holds a place in my heart), but it did enrich my Sisters reportoire.

I held out a few weeks with these, meanwhile doscovering the clip of Walk Away and the Wake versions of Alice, Marian and First and Last and Always and Body and Soul. I began to appreciate the Sisters more and read more about them. After a few weeks I succeeded in downloading a few more songs with regular intervals, first including Sister Ray then Suzanne- the first two Live songs I had ever gotten, and Suzanne the first of the- for me unknown as of yet- latest Sisters productions.

Then came the great day, at March 6 2007- I joined Heartland! I had visited Sisterswiki dot com and 1959 for lyrics explanation, which led me here. I was interested and decided to join to learn more about the Sisters.
Before I posted anything else I got myhands on more songs, which led to the following new selection:

Suzanne 03/03/2007/18:20:35
Sister Ray 03/03/2007/18:20:38
Poison Door 09/03/2007/20:10:21
Sandstorm 09/03/2007/20:10:31
Detonation Boulevard 09/03/2007/20:18:10
Gimme Shelter 09/03/2007/20:19:16
Flood II 09/03/2007/20:20:11
When You Don't See Me 09/03/2007/20:27:46
On the Wire 09/03/2007/00:23:55
Knocking on Heaven's Door 10/03/2007/10:15:38
Silver Machine(live) 10/03/2007/10:15:53
Teachers 10/03/2007/10:20:15
Flood I 10/03/2007/00:41:15
Bury Me Deep 10/03/2007/10:43:50
Afterhours 10/03/2007/00:26:13

Flood I and II were songs I was really curious about- not having a clue about hw they sounded. At first I liked Flood I better, but soon Flood II began to take over, then overwhelm me with its quality- and the third Sisters song on my Nr.1 list ever took its place: Flood II!

Then, I did my first post. I liked TOL 92 alot but Sisterswiki told me there was an original! a 83 version! never having heard it, I was unable to find it and asked for help:
Tidal wrote: Hello, I'm new on these forums. AAnd I have a question for all that could answer it; I've been looking for
The Original Temple of Love/Heartland 1983 single for ages- no TRACE of it on the web Crying or Very sad

So I wonder if it's even available at all? I'd nearly do a KILL to hear the original- The 1992 is, I think the Sister's Best song and that's how I learnt of them- it was included in a video clip about something as a track, and I thought WOW...had to know who made it.

But I heard of some interview with Eldritch in which he says the original is even faster, and ofc does not have Ofra's voice in it. I have also heard it was a huge hit back then (83) and, together with Alice, defined the pre-FALAA era of the Sisters. So it got me wondering, how exactly does it sound? ANd where can I get it?
Then Mh told me how to get it, welcomed me to Heartland. SGWBM was recommended to me by various people. I also explained how it all started in THAT post- rather fast, but useful since I do not remember everything right now :wink: this is the post for who is interested...
http://www.myheartland.co.uk/viewtopic. ... highlight=
Then DrG was so nice to link a TOL '83 download- yay, I had it :D
The post then changed into a discussion about downloading stuff rather than buying it.

A few quotes from my early days on HL:
Tidal wrote:Driven Like the Snow, Something Fast, Under the Gun and Heartland had my liking
I began PM-ing with _emma_...
Tidal wrote:I don't really dislike any sisters song (I even begin to like Damage Done as a catchy song Surprised ), but I find a few of them plain boring..
Home of the Hitmen (lol. if anyone likes that..)
Burn
Burn it down
Possession
...and their covers. Most of them suck. Gimme Shelter is ok, but they screwed up Knockin'...
Tidal wrote: guess I gotta put a few songs in a "never listened to before" folder, or I'm gonna hate myself for already knowing all songs before I've really gotten the feeling Razz
Dr.Moody wrote: Say YES to excess! :von:
I had in those days decided to buy Floodland because I liked it so much. I got the re-issue from Amazone and loved it.

And I proceeded to delve deep into Heartland and the Sisters, my later download list looking like this:

Temple of Love '83 11/03/2007/10:30:40
comfortably Numb(live) 12/03/2007/09:59:47
(Jolene(live)) 12/03/2007/11:22:39
(Emma(live)) 12/03/2007/11:22:57
Torch 13/03/2007/20:34:26
You Could Be the One 13/03/2007/20:49:10
Amphetamine Logic 13/03/2007/20:49:15
Jolene 13/03/2007/20:49:38
Blood Money 13/03/2007/21:14:19
First and Last and Always 13/03/2007/21:14:36
Fix 13/03/2007/22:59:30
Colours(eldritch version) 14/03/2007/09:17:42
Body and Soul 14/03/2007/09:30:57
Kiss the Carpet 15/03/2007/10:01:32
Will I Dream 19/03/2007/21:24:17
Where Spirits Fly(demo) 22/03/2007/20:57:29
Train 24/03/2007/14:55:23
Confide In Me(live) 03/04/2007/18:19:31
Driver 05/04/2007/18:06:31
Rain From Heaven 05/04/2007/18:30:36
Gimme Gimme Gimme(live) 05/04/2007/18:31:19
Romeo Down 05/04/2007/18:52:24
Finland Red, Egypt White 05/04/2007/19:18:53
Ghost Riders In the Sky(live) 06/04/2007/18:12:06
(Walk Away(demo)) 08/04/2007/18:53:01
(Floorshow(demo)) 08/04/2007/18:53:04
(No Time to Cry(demo)) 08/04/2007/18:53:07
(Fix(Craig Adams version)) 08/04/2007/18:53:12
(Train(demo)) 08/04/2007/18:53:27
Wide Receiver 08/04/2007/18:53:31
Red Skies Disappear 08/04/2007/18:53:37
Lights 12/04/2007/23:13:25
(Marian(instrumental version)) 14/04/2007/13:59:15
Jihad 15/04/2007/12:52:30
Vision Thing(extended) 15/04/2007/13:12:03
(When You Don't See Me(german version)) 21/04/2007/13:48:12
(Temple of Love '92(german version)) 21/04/2007/15:42:40
Dance On Glass 21/04/2007/15:43:46
Summer 21/04/2007/19:09:50
Giving Ground 21/04/2007/19:13:15
Ozymandias 21/04/2007/20:47:38
(Black Planet(karaoke version)) 21/04/2007/21:34:48
Good Things 22/04/2007/17:26:57
(Marian(karaoke version)) 24/04/2007/18:04:39
(Valentine(version #1)) 24/04/2007/18:04:49
Untitled(Dominion version) 27/04/2007/23:45:51
Lucretia 06/05/2007/09:12:23
Long Train 06/05/2007/09:34:11
Emma 10/05/2007/15:01:32
Ghostrider(live) 10/05/2007/15:10:39
Two In the Nose 18/05/2007/16:41:24
Bad Vultee 18/05/2007/16:46:21
Gone 18/05/2007/16:53:10
Knife, Paper, Stone and Guns 18/05/2007/17:10:17
Nice 18/05/2007/17:12:21
Drugsar 18/05/2007/17:12:21
High School 18/05/2007/17:12:22
Go Figure 18/05/2007/17:30:30
Feel No Pain 18/05/2007/17:44:38
Shut the f**k Up 18/05/2007/17:44:38

NRUB 03/06/2007/17:47:52
Body Electric '84 03/06/2007/19:19:16
Spirits(demo) 04/06/2007/00:32:20
(Flood I(demo)) 04/06/2007/00:32:32
Slept 06/07/2007/16:33:18
Still 06/07/2007/16:33:19
Top Nite Out 06/07/2007/16:33:20
(This Corrosion(demo)) 13/08/2007/14:35:35

I bought First and Last and Always(the re-issue) later on. I was very impressed because the coherence between the songs was much better than Floodland's, and there was a feeling like Andy had just been moreinvolved with FALAA. I had a great time listening to it over na dover again with a headphone on vacation.

And then there was Zottegem 07/07/07... The first gig, the first sigh tof the Sisters. Quite an experience- although I should have heard another recent full live gig BEFORE going to Zottegem (but I hadn't discovered the Sharing forums yet :innocent: ), because the quality and style of the songs was completely different from what I had expected. After hearing London Forum 2003, I knew Zottegem hadn't been anything unusual(except it's quality).


I will add more when i remember stuff! Feel free to tell of YOUR sisters history!
Last edited by Tidal on 15 Sep 2007, 22:54, edited 1 time in total.
It's good to be back
User avatar
itnAklipse
Slight Overbomber
Posts: 1541
Joined: 09 Jun 2003, 08:12
Location: set adrift
Contact:

Good heavens. No i didn't read all that :lol:
we've got beer and we've got fuel
User avatar
CellThree
Slight Overbomber
Posts: 1730
Joined: 14 Feb 2003, 22:05
Location: 4200 miles from my record collection
Contact:

Tidal wrote:Feel free to tell of YOUR sisters history!
If you do a search, I think it was a couple of years back, you'll find a thread that was something along the lines of "How did you first hear The Sisters?" or something along those lines.
24.24.2.489 Deceased
User avatar
6FeetOver
Childlike Empress
Posts: 7683
Joined: 25 Jan 2002, 00:00
Location: way on down south, New London town...
Contact:

You mean, this one? ;)
I left my heart in Ballycastle... :cry: :cry: :cry:
User avatar
smiscandlon
Overbomber
Posts: 2595
Joined: 05 Feb 2004, 23:52

Tidal wrote:my musical obsession
No, really? :innocent:

:lol:
анархия
User avatar
Ozpat
From the Lowlands
Posts: 6758
Joined: 16 Aug 2005, 13:14
Location: In the place through which we wander.

I love your enthousiasm Ivo!

Nice read! :wink:
"as we walk on the floodland"
User avatar
CellThree
Slight Overbomber
Posts: 1730
Joined: 14 Feb 2003, 22:05
Location: 4200 miles from my record collection
Contact:

SINsister wrote:You mean, this one? ;)
That's the kiddie!
24.24.2.489 Deceased
User avatar
nowayjose
Utterly Bastard Groovy Amphetamine Filth
Posts: 539
Joined: 19 Mar 2006, 02:15
Location: Berlin

Tidal wrote: I then used my basic downloading tool, Limewire, to try and find some Sisters stuff. From then on, I have downloaded over a hundred files, of which I have the chronological order stored in my PC. I was able to make a list.
How about buying the music, you cheap bastard? :roll:

I mean, downloading something occasionally is fine by me, especially for evaluation purposes, but to shamelessly brag about it on a public forum is rather audacious, imho. Maybe I'm a bit old-fashioned.
User avatar
Tidal
Gonzoid Amphetamine Filth
Posts: 442
Joined: 06 Mar 2007, 11:50
Location: The Hollow Land

nowayjose wrote:
Tidal wrote: I then used my basic downloading tool, Limewire, to try and find some Sisters stuff. From then on, I have downloaded over a hundred files, of which I have the chronological order stored in my PC. I was able to make a list.
How about buying the music, you cheap bastard? :roll:

I mean, downloading something occasionally is fine by me, especially for evaluation purposes, but to shamelessly brag about it on a public forum is rather audacious, imho. Maybe I'm a bit old-fashioned.
... and we're back to my first post :lol: :lol: :lol:
http://www.myheartland.co.uk/viewtopic. ... c&start=25
It's good to be back
User avatar
smiscandlon
Overbomber
Posts: 2595
Joined: 05 Feb 2004, 23:52

Tidal wrote:If you can give me ANY link to a sisters album/single available on the mainland for less than 5 euros, ill buy it, just because I like the Sisters and buying something instead of downing it is a statement of appreciation.
You see, not a cheap bastard by any stretch of the imagination...
анархия
User avatar
Purple Light
Slight Overbomber
Posts: 1526
Joined: 02 Feb 2004, 16:25
Location: Kirkstall
Contact:

I love your posts Tidal! (Need a good while to sit & read them of course...)

For what its worth, my (brief) history is as follows...

My Dad heard Some Kind Of Stranger in a Manchester record shop in the early 90's. He bought F&L&A as a result. I thought it was great & thus fell in love. Obsession really began when I heard You Could Be The One for the first time. :innocent: :lol:
“I got lost in the mirror, wondering what could have been, I couldn’t help but kill her, but I couldn’t kill the dream.”
User avatar
James Blast
Banned
Posts: 24699
Joined: 11 Jun 2003, 18:58
Location: back from some place else

I respect your post, many may not :lol:
"And when you start to think about death, you start to think about what's after it. And then you start hoping there is a God. For me, it's a frightening thought to go nowhere".
~ Peter Steele
User avatar
Ed Rhombus
Slight Overbomber
Posts: 1328
Joined: 10 May 2002, 01:00
Location: West Yorkshire
Contact:

More a case of lacking the stamina need to read such a lenghty declaration with me James.

Curse you God, for making me this way!
Ed Rhombus

There for you (weather permiting)

www.rhombus-rock.com
https://www.facebook.com/rhombus.uk
User avatar
6FeetOver
Childlike Empress
Posts: 7683
Joined: 25 Jan 2002, 00:00
Location: way on down south, New London town...
Contact:

Purple Light wrote:I love your posts Tidal! (Need a good while to sit & read them of course...)

For what its worth, my (brief) history is as follows...

My Dad heard Some Kind Of Stranger in a Manchester record shop in the early 90's. He bought F&L&A as a result. I thought it was great & thus fell in love. Obsession really began when I heard You Could Be The One for the first time. :innocent: :lol:
Your dad rocks. \m/ :von:
I left my heart in Ballycastle... :cry: :cry: :cry:
User avatar
Ozpat
From the Lowlands
Posts: 6758
Joined: 16 Aug 2005, 13:14
Location: In the place through which we wander.

Tidal wrote:
nowayjose wrote:
Tidal wrote: I then used my basic downloading tool, Limewire, to try and find some Sisters stuff. From then on, I have downloaded over a hundred files, of which I have the chronological order stored in my PC. I was able to make a list.
How about buying the music, you cheap bastard? :roll:

I mean, downloading something occasionally is fine by me, especially for evaluation purposes, but to shamelessly brag about it on a public forum is rather audacious, imho. Maybe I'm a bit old-fashioned.
... and we're back to my first post :lol: :lol: :lol:
http://www.myheartland.co.uk/viewtopic. ... c&start=25
:lol: :notworthy:
"as we walk on the floodland"
User avatar
paul
Overbomber
Posts: 3219
Joined: 02 Apr 2002, 01:00

Tidal, you have an irritating kind of enthousiasm... :urff:
User avatar
6FeetOver
Childlike Empress
Posts: 7683
Joined: 25 Jan 2002, 00:00
Location: way on down south, New London town...
Contact:

paul wrote:Tidal, you have an irritating kind of enthousiasm... :urff:
Hey, man, don't knock it! At least he's found something to be so "irritatingly" enthusiastic about, eh? Most of us should be so lucky... ;)



Keep on keepin' on, Tidal! ;D
I left my heart in Ballycastle... :cry: :cry: :cry:
User avatar
cardoman
Slight Overbomber
Posts: 1541
Joined: 26 Aug 2007, 19:23
Location: Where the lights shine on the aluminium

SINsister wrote:
paul wrote:Tidal, you have an irritating kind of enthousiasm... :urff:
Hey, man, don't knock it! At least he's found something to be so "irritatingly" enthusiastic about, eh? Most of us should be so lucky... ;)



Keep on keepin' on, Tidal! ;D
Yes Tidal keep your enthousiam, nothing wrong with that! Unfortunetely not as much time to put everything on the record here but a lot of enthousiam about sisters too.

Grtz
Was it Alice or our daughter Ellice???
User avatar
Purple Light
Slight Overbomber
Posts: 1526
Joined: 02 Feb 2004, 16:25
Location: Kirkstall
Contact:

SINsister wrote:
Purple Light wrote:I love your posts Tidal! (Need a good while to sit & read them of course...)

For what its worth, my (brief) history is as follows...

My Dad heard Some Kind Of Stranger in a Manchester record shop in the early 90's. He bought F&L&A as a result. I thought it was great & thus fell in love. Obsession really began when I heard You Could Be The One for the first time. :innocent: :lol:
Your dad rocks. \m/ :von:
Indeed he does Sinny. :von:

I grew up on Bowie, Pistols, Buzzocks, Bauhaus, Clash etc all thanks to him. :notworthy:

I want another long Tidal post to read!
“I got lost in the mirror, wondering what could have been, I couldn’t help but kill her, but I couldn’t kill the dream.”
User avatar
6FeetOver
Childlike Empress
Posts: 7683
Joined: 25 Jan 2002, 00:00
Location: way on down south, New London town...
Contact:

:eek: :notworthy: Hip dad! Damn. I wish I'd had one... :roll:
I left my heart in Ballycastle... :cry: :cry: :cry:
User avatar
more-sedatives-pls
Gonzoid Amphetamine Filth
Posts: 304
Joined: 15 Feb 2006, 17:23
Location: Leuven, Belgium

2121 words...... :eek: :eek:

is that a HL record?

Anyhowz, I've read quite a few of those, so it was an interesting read Tidal!

I got in touch with Front and Sisters around '90, and they took over fairly instantaneously iirc.
I've been a boring git ever since; people I know tell me I don't evolve. People I know really well do, however, agree ;D
I started with FL and FALAA, was surprised to hear other stuff at my first gig in Gent, then got into VT, the old stuff and the live stuff. Started going for demos. Still not into collecting all the live gigs [apart from 83 and 84].

Now, howz that for a 117 word resume? :lol:



you should BUY more stuff though.....
Immodium for the people
theyoungbrain
Road Kill
Posts: 49
Joined: 09 Sep 2006, 10:11
Location: england
Contact:

1989... diamond dicky dowson played me FLAA and i was hooked. saw a few gigs, bought the records and am still lurking around the sisters today.

don't collect sisters stuff but like to get demos, some live stuff and rare stuff downloaded (or on c90's back a few years).

best sisters memory is sitting in a dingy student room watching Wake for the first time, was just so into it! dunno why that one but it just sticks in the mind.
blood instead of rain...
User avatar
dinky daisy
Slight Overbomber
Posts: 1030
Joined: 08 Apr 2006, 14:25
Location: amsterdamned

you are sick.
guns & cars & accidents
User avatar
Tidal
Gonzoid Amphetamine Filth
Posts: 442
Joined: 06 Mar 2007, 11:50
Location: The Hollow Land

dinky daisy wrote:you are sick.

:eek:
That's quite the statement my fellow countryman, care to explain?
It's good to be back
User avatar
6FeetOver
Childlike Empress
Posts: 7683
Joined: 25 Jan 2002, 00:00
Location: way on down south, New London town...
Contact:

Yeah, that was a tad uncalled-for, dinky daisy.
I left my heart in Ballycastle... :cry: :cry: :cry:
Post Reply