I don't think I've ever read those two, which would account for my not remembering!DeWinter wrote:Re-read "He" and "The Horror of Red Hook" for the last bit.
Tying it loosely back to the point of the thread, Lovecraft categorised himself himself as an atheist, and his horror stories reflect that. No God, no meaning to life, and man just a speck in the universe at the mercy of beings completely unfathomable, truly alien, with no discernible motives or recognisable emotions. I think that's what makes his stories so chilling.
While I get what you're saying about Lovecraft's view of humanity's insignificance, I don't think that's what made them chill me personally. I think that, despite the shortcomings of his prose and his sometimes hilarious melodramatic tendencies, he somehow had a way of making them seem absolutely real (as with the example I gave from ATMOM). No matter how ridiculous the ideas or the telling, you believed that the narrator was recounting horrors that they'd actually seen and that haunted them forever after or even drove them insane. In fact, perhaps those very shortcomings added to that feeling: these weren't well crafted works of fiction but the rougher edged and sometimes deranged accounts of real people.