Well, I've seen the first part now, and DLing the second part, which I will watch within two hours or so
I'm all with MarkFiend here, enjoyed it quite a bit! Maybe because me and the Missus are big Pratchett fans as well, and are also used to his humour (and I mean ALL his humour, coz we got ALL his books hehe).
Some minor points:
-Susan is a complete mis-casting. She looks more like a stern but worried young mother than a granddaughter of Death. She has to be more cool and reserved, more I-don't-give-a-feckness factor. Big thumbs down, because she has a big part in the movie, so I have to watch her face way too often and thus she annoys me a lot.
-The Voice of Death does a good job, but I fear I've been heavily spoiled with hearing Christopher Lee doing Death's Voice on the 'Soul Music' cartoon... Now THAT was how I always imagined Death!
This guy is sometimes quite happy-souding and I'm not talking about the times he tries to be more Hogfather-ly. But he'll do.
-The Auditors reminded me of the Marx Brothers, and two of them act all silly as if they are several aces short of a full stack. They have to be neutral, reserved, and COOL.
-Teatime's trademark laughter just does not work for me.
-what the FECK were they thinking when they gave the 'Tooth Guards' that silly helmet?
It looks like Willy Wonka and the Colgate Factory!
The nice stuff:
-almost followed the book to the letter, which is never bad of course!
even the Money Pulleys in the Mall are there, and the Pig doing a wee...
-I really liked Nobby Nobbs, although he shows off his false teeth just a bit too often. But Nobbs/Visit works very well!
-Albert is also very nice, and I really hope they give him a fag at the end of this series... poor lad
-I did like the Archchancellor a lot, he even LOOKS the part, IMO. Not so sure about the others, tho... Although Ponder Stibbons is quite OK. And so is HEX
-and, apart from his laughter, Teatime is very good. It took me a while to 'get into' him, he looks quite different as I would picture him, but...well...it works. The little mannerisms, his air, his speech (with the pauses and the volume changes), very good effort and well thought out IMO.
Now waiting for the second part to DL.
And MAKE a WHOLE MOVIE, someone!
IZ.