markfiend wrote: ↑24 Sep 2021, 13:19
If we're talking about the same thing as @Dan's upload in the old thread I don't think it's the Sisters.
It's all just midi files - I don't think there's a live musician on there at all.
Ah! I'd forgotten all about that. And the link still works. Oh well, that's peoples curiosity sated anyway. Hopefully nobody shelled out any money on the records!
Being645 wrote: ↑25 Sep 2021, 09:21
I guess, these are mere old Doktor demos giving orientation for band members to what dynamics the sound should have live.
Well, they should sound like the Doktor then
They don't. They sound like out of the box samples.
And they don't sound like the live tracks. They're cluttered, messy with no space for guitar parts. If they were written by a guitarist there would be tons of space to fill + it's actually easier for a guitarist to play the parts than programme them.
Even the dates don't make sense, why would tracks written after the songs public debut not sound like the song?
Being645 wrote: ↑25 Sep 2021, 09:21
I guess, these are mere old Doktor demos giving orientation for band members to what dynamics the sound should have live.
Well, they should sound like the Doktor then
They don't. They sound like out of the box samples.
And they don't sound like the live tracks. They're cluttered, messy with no space for guitar parts. If they were written by a guitarist there would be tons of space to fill + it's actually easier for a guitarist to play the parts than programme them.
Even the dates don't make sense, why would tracks written after the songs public debut not sound like the song?
Being645 wrote: ↑25 Sep 2021, 09:21
I guess, these are mere old Doktor demos giving orientation for band members to what dynamics the sound should have live.
Well, they should sound like the Doktor then
They don't. They sound like out of the box samples.
And they don't sound like the live tracks. They're cluttered, messy with no space for guitar parts. If they were written by a guitarist there would be tons of space to fill + it's actually easier for a guitarist to play the parts than programme them.
Even the dates don't make sense, why would tracks written after the songs public debut not sound like the song?
True. I stand corrected ... ...
Don't take my word for it!
I think the onus is on proving they're real but I'm just not feeling it.
Yeah, Top Nite Out is the only one that's actually any good, but none of the rest even sound like the songs as we know them, although Crash & Burn could make a case for being a (very distant) second best.
These will turn out to have been someone noodling in their bedroom with a PC, nothing more.
mh wrote: ↑25 Sep 2021, 11:06
Yeah, Top Nite Out is the only one that's actually any good, but none of the rest even sound like the songs as we know them, although Crash & Burn could make a case for being a (very distant) second best.
These will turn out to have been someone noodling in their bedroom with a PC, nothing more.
The "guitar" overdubs are nothing but a synth with some buzzsaw distortion added. The chorus in Summer is wrong. The "Doktor" sounds pretty damn cheap and crappy. I hadn't listened to it for years but I am still not convinced this is the real deal after listening to this again. Bare in mind I only made it to song number 3 though.
oh come on folks! these are as obviously fake as wide reciever was obviously andrew. maybe a stint in the FB pond or dominion would help...
EDIT for the record top nite out would still have been called snubnose
eastmidswhizzkid wrote: ↑03 Oct 2021, 22:36
oh come on folks! these are as obviously fake as wide reciever was obviously andrew. maybe a stint in the FB pond or dominion would help...
EDIT for the record top nite out would still have been called snubnose
eastmidswhizzkid wrote: ↑03 Oct 2021, 22:36
oh come on folks! these are as obviously fake as wide reciever was obviously andrew. maybe a stint in the FB pond or dominion would help...
EDIT for the record top nite out would still have been called snubnose
eastmidswhizzkid wrote: ↑03 Oct 2021, 22:36
oh come on folks! these are as obviously fake as wide reciever was obviously andrew. maybe a stint in the FB pond or dominion would help...
EDIT for the record top nite out would still have been called snubnose
ah yes- thanks Ez. the similiarity is even more noticeable if you jigger the bpm up to match. not an out-and-out steal, like say, when you dont see me/ rainbow in the dark , but not dissimilar.
...
maybe a stint in the FB pond or dominion would help... 
