Heartland

Posted: **11 Mar 2009, 21:52**

I'm pretty sure AE faxed the Editor of NME with a note "Happy Headache" when "This Corrosion" charted.

Posted: **11 Mar 2009, 23:07**

This article is pure bs, but that's quite obvious

However, I didn't know the White Lies before and their song (or part of it) strongly reminds me of Joy Division (somehow a mixture of She's lost control and Love will tear us apart). I will check out the White Lies (if they have released any album yet), so at least one positive thing

Posted: **11 Mar 2009, 23:09**

Without any Bach, Mahler, Wagner and countless others then this list is modern rubbish. Style over substance

blackness in lieu of bohemia

thanks for saving me the trouble of

reading this

Posted: **12 Mar 2009, 11:07**

I made a couple of comments too, as, er, Derek.

So I have my shortlist of 17 Goff tunes.

Pista

Posted: **12 Mar 2009, 12:54**

This was you?

Can you play to your strengths and go back to discussing Pete Doherty's hats please?

I didn't even click that we could post comments until now.

I do like this though

This post has 1 feedback awaiting moderation...

They moderate them?
I dread to think what Steve Earl Goth's post said before they moderated it.

Posted: **12 Mar 2009, 14:16**

Pista wrote:This was you?
Can you play to your strengths and go back to discussing Pete Doherty's hats please?

It was me. I remember making a posting on another music forum about 2005 called "Oh NME where did it all go wrong?" after idly browsing a copy of the mag. like a music version of Heat for those with candyfloss for frontal lobes.

Pista wrote:
I didn't even click that we could post comments until now.

I do like this though
This post has 1 feedback awaiting moderation...
They moderate them?
I dread to think what Steve Earl Goth's post said before they moderated it.

that's the one in caps?

Once more with feeling Steve

Posted: **12 Mar 2009, 14:21**

I wrote:"If there's an instinctive cringe when the term goth is invoked, that's because"... of the NME's attitude to goth, which has variously been to vilify, to ridicule, or to ignore. And you're surprised when goths turn up to slag you off?

Posted: **12 Mar 2009, 16:41**

markfiend wrote:
I wrote:"If there's an instinctive cringe when the term goth is invoked, that's because"... of the NME's attitude to goth, which has variously been to vilify, to ridicule, or to ignore. And you're surprised when goths turn up to slag you off?

You sure it doesn't have anything to do with vampires? I mean, I generally think that vampires ought to be vilified, ridiculed and ignored. I mean, they're the living dead for Christ's sake! You know your neighborhood is shot once they move in.

Posted: **13 Mar 2009, 00:36**

Luke Lewis wrote:...the fact is, none of us like Rosetta Stone, or Fields Of The Nephilim, or The m*****n. Some of us *do* like Joy Division, Manics, The Horrors etc. But none of this is stopping you lot from suggesting your *own* 20 greatest goth tracks. So here's my promise: If enough of you post your own Top 20 lists as a comment below (say, at least 20), I'll aggregate them and post a *new* greatest goth tracks list, based on your choices. How's that?

Come on then heartlanders. What should this list look like then? Try and give some mention to some post 1980's bands, that's what the NME has always tried to boycott afterall!

Posted: **13 Mar 2009, 00:56**

Luke Lewis wrote:Please write my own articles for free, I realise that t'interweb means I no longer have to pay journalists. Tee hee!

No. Pay me.

Posted: **13 Mar 2009, 09:18**

Try and give some mention to some post 1980's bands

I tried. I failed.

Then I remembered that post-80s goth is actually legitimately s**t, and went off to listen to the true successors, which included Tindersticks, Portishead, and even some Pulp. Gulp.

Posted: **13 Mar 2009, 09:31**

Luke Lewis, IMO, has nothing to do with Goth and he is not able to judge.

if Rosetta Stone, or Fields Of The Nephilim, or The m*****n are not mentioned in the top 20 goth songs.....well, it's not a top 20 goth songs

Posted: **13 Mar 2009, 10:35**

don't forget boney m

Posted: **13 Mar 2009, 13:00**

Quiff Boy wrote:don't forget boney m

& the theme to Eastenders

Posted: **13 Mar 2009, 14:30**

And Watership Down

Posted: **13 Mar 2009, 15:31**

Mini PiB generally sneers at post 80â€™s goth, but tracks that get her attention include:

Orbital ~ Satan
Sneaker Pimps ~ Long hard road out of hell
Moby ~ New dawn fades (which she asserts is better than the original)
Girls Aloud ~ sound of the underground
Sugababes~ ugly

But then, mini PiB is probably an EMO

For me: little mention, if any, of the Furs, or JAMC [Darklands period?]

Posted: **13 Mar 2009, 20:58**

Gene loves Jezebel?

Posted: **13 Mar 2009, 21:03**

psichonaut wrote:Gene loves Jezebel?

Now you've taken the joke too far

Posted: **13 Mar 2009, 23:27**

weebleswobble wrote:
psichonaut wrote:Gene loves Jezebel?
Now you've taken the joke too far

There was a joke?

Posted: **14 Mar 2009, 00:06**

well, "promise" was a good goth album

Posted: **14 Mar 2009, 13:19**

I'm glad you all enjoyed the article, I came accross it during a quiet day in work

Posted: **14 Mar 2009, 18:16**

Victim of Circumstance wrote: However, I didn't know the White Lies before:

their debut album is really good and if you check their website you may still find it with an extra limited booklet

Posted: **16 Mar 2009, 15:27**

Seeing the Dulka Prague Away kit (

by the way) reminded me that the Biccies paeon to Welsh Goth isn't mentioned either...

Posted: **16 Mar 2009, 15:30**

Broadstairs either!

Posted: **19 Mar 2009, 23:47**

DJ Bobo is the best post-80s goth band.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SJGjRVIdeeQ

Heartland

Top 20 Goth Tracks - according to NME