Posted: 22 Nov 2011, 11:14
the reality is that regardless of band or venue, the sound is never perfect everywhere
i went to see carter usm last week and the sound was shocking. the middle range was non existent and the bottom end eq was distorted and f**ked so bad you could only feel it, not actually hear it... the net effect was that the whole thing sounded like a swamp of noise
i went to see the damned the next night at exactly the same venue and stood in exactly the same place, and it wasn't much better.
likewise i went to see kmfdm at a different venue a couple of days before and stood front-left for most of the gig and it was shocking there. all you could hear where the drums. then i wandered to the middle of the venue and it was crystal clear. i've seen the cult where you couldn't hear anything other than billy's guitar. i've seen grinderman where all you could hear was nick and the bass.
all venues have pockets where the sound is great and where the sound is shocking. my personal experience would suggest the more electronic a band's bass and drums, the less suited to huge echoey cavernous venues (like manchester academy 1) they are, as it all tends to merge into one thick fwapp sound
i've been to see the sisters where the sound is shocking, but i've also been to see them where it's amazing.
don't blame the sisters - an iffy live sound is by no means exclusive to them.
and the fact that as many people at the same gig experience GOOD sound as experience BAD would suggest that it's very much down to personal taste and where you're stood
i went to see carter usm last week and the sound was shocking. the middle range was non existent and the bottom end eq was distorted and f**ked so bad you could only feel it, not actually hear it... the net effect was that the whole thing sounded like a swamp of noise
i went to see the damned the next night at exactly the same venue and stood in exactly the same place, and it wasn't much better.
likewise i went to see kmfdm at a different venue a couple of days before and stood front-left for most of the gig and it was shocking there. all you could hear where the drums. then i wandered to the middle of the venue and it was crystal clear. i've seen the cult where you couldn't hear anything other than billy's guitar. i've seen grinderman where all you could hear was nick and the bass.
all venues have pockets where the sound is great and where the sound is shocking. my personal experience would suggest the more electronic a band's bass and drums, the less suited to huge echoey cavernous venues (like manchester academy 1) they are, as it all tends to merge into one thick fwapp sound
i've been to see the sisters where the sound is shocking, but i've also been to see them where it's amazing.
don't blame the sisters - an iffy live sound is by no means exclusive to them.
and the fact that as many people at the same gig experience GOOD sound as experience BAD would suggest that it's very much down to personal taste and where you're stood