Heartland

The video from Sisters of Murphy live with Crash and Burn was thumbsdown
perhaps it is not the best version ever in this cover but certainly not only a thumbsdown :s

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PqJZOLj7rAs

i gave a thumbsup to this, i think the murphs deserve it

more human than human

Musically not deserving of the thumbs down ... but I can't help feeling that, especially when they've all gone to so much trouble to replicate the sound, instruments, sartorial elegance etc, perhaps the singers barnett could do with just a little more work.

The video sucks big time in terms of recording quality so what's the problem with a thumbs down if the package looks and sounds just bad. Do I need to start a thread for any thumbs down I got for my vids over the years or may I continue not caring about this?

Take it on the chin big man

Without comments it's impossible to know quite which aspect the thumbs are directed at ... could be the quality ... could be the overall content ... could be anything really.

to clear things up. my post was trying to say that they make a far better job of it than what tours as A Sisters Of Mercy these days, it's got bass for one thing, never mind a bloke that can actually sing, then there's Mia - that just ices the cake for me

what's the thumb down all about?

I got through 13 seconds.

When the audio quality is that bad, it's probably better to not post it to youtube at all.

it is getting better after 15-20 secs

If you cannot stand a thumbsdown now and then you should not stay into music business. It never bothers me, and I think the Smurphs think the same way.

IZ.

phew! Too much movement, give that girl a tambourine and some tranqs.

Izzy HaveMercy wrote:If you cannot stand a thumbsdown now and then you should not stay into music business. It never bothers me, and I think the Smurphs think the same way.

IZ.

Agreed!