Heartland

What is this?? I have found it recently. Could this be real because it seems quite pro? (or someone has been very skillful)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tMfbG6iwllM

Fake.

Uploaded by "Elsie Baggs" who, according to Google/YouTube, is this person:

https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC3SbGG ... freload=10

They have also uploaded live vids by The Sisters, James Ray and The Manc Lads (:!:), including one with footage filmed by our very own Snowey.

Regardless of quality (some of it's ok, and some is very iffy indeed) I'd suggest the source rules out any claim to legitimacy.

Thanks for the info! As I cannot delete this topic if you agree with it, please delete it.

Yeah, I'm not buying it either.
They seem far too polished for demos & a bit feeble really.
I would have expected a really walloping bass/ rhythm section

@ Joy: There's no need to delete the thread.... I'm happy to leave it here as a discussion point

Quiff Boy wrote:@ Joy: There's no need to delete the thread.... I'm happy to leave it here as a discussion point

Okay... (I admit Top Nite Out and C&B quite deceived me )

Joy wrote:

Quiff Boy wrote:@ Joy: There's no need to delete the thread.... I'm happy to leave it here as a discussion point

Okay... (I admit Top Nite Out and C&B quite deceived me )

They are the best two tracks

Joy wrote:What is this?? I have found it recently. Could this be real because it seems quite pro? (or someone has been very skillful)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tMfbG6iwllM

Anyway, this track is a nice find, Joy ... ...

No reason to delete it!

I found this untitled third song pretty decent btw.

Quiff Boy wrote:Fake.

Uploaded by "Elsie Baggs" who, according to Google/YouTube, is this person:

https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC3SbGG ... freload=10

They have also uploaded live vids by The Sisters, James Ray and The Manc Lads (:!:), including one with footage filmed by our very own Snowey.

Regardless of quality (some of it's ok, and some is very iffy indeed) I'd suggest the source rules out any claim to legitimacy.

Nowt to do with me chief as I've never filmed the sisters. Violets / Fall / NMA etc etc yes but never the sisters.

Nabbed Top Nite Out for a ringtone; at least it's served some purpose!

Thy may not be instrumentals at all. They could just be the Sisters live with Von's voice lost in the awful mix as usual.

Husek wrote:I found this untitled third song pretty decent btw.

Try singing the Far Parade lyrics to it.

It's a pity he made it private though it was really enjoyable. (Has anyone by any chance downloaded it? )

Joy wrote:It's a pity he made it private though it was really enjoyable. (Has anyone by any chance downloaded it? )

Why of course, what site do you kids use for sharing these days?

https://www.dropbox.com/s/s47xi2pr7dm3v ... 9.mp4?dl=0

Hopefully this will work.

Pat wrote:https://www.dropbox.com/s/s47xi2pr7dm3v ... 9.mp4?dl=0

Hopefully this will work.

Many thanks!

Vaguely apropos, there's also this soundcheck of an unheard song from a few years ago:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lR9BUu9RHtY

This is the real Sisters, at least.

Joy wrote:

Pat wrote:https://www.dropbox.com/s/s47xi2pr7dm3v ... 9.mp4?dl=0

Hopefully this will work.

Many thanks!

404 Not Found. I was curious given the discussion above- apparently at least some of 'em are decently produced?

Pista wrote:Yeah, I'm not buying it either.
They seem far too polished for demos & a bit feeble really.
I would have expected a really walloping bass/ rhythm section

Listening to it now (thanks!) I know people whose demos are this polished. Hell, so are mine. Comes with being a recording geek. It's mostly synth, looped bass, and drum machine anyhow- not hard to record cleanly. Guitars sound very much direct into the board, which is a fan of. If I knew nothing about the source, it wouldn't actually surprise me- it's lack of vocals that makes me suspect they're not? Some of the drum sounds in there seem more... Modern than what I'm used to in a Sisters context, but I'd hope there'd at least be some change over the years.

Given the sound of the live rhythm section, this is roughly what I'd expect. I'd hope for a walloping one, but then I'd expect just as much walloping live.

Someone spent some time with this. Given what I know re: his gear-tweakingness and taste in things, I might expect 's demos to sound roughly like this. Again, no vocals though, and I would expect there to be vocals.[/i]

Bummer, I was curious to hear that too…

Can someone post a link for these files?

https://www.mediafire.com/?1y7xicry6ona1ex

And from the youtube description...

1. Crash & Burn
2. Romeo Down
3. ?????????
4. Top Night Out
5. Summer

Thank you for the new link @Dan.

Thanks for the link Dan.

I remember why I forgot about these.

s**t fakes.