Body Electric 82 or 84?
Posted: 08 Nov 2003, 19:35
The original or the one on the Body And Soul 12". I ain't gonna give you a cop out option.
Page 1 of 2
Posted: 08 Nov 2003, 19:41
no explenation here ...
Posted: 08 Nov 2003, 19:45
You don't understand the question?13Vision13 wrote:no explenation here ...
Posted: 08 Nov 2003, 20:16
Already answered this in the Alice poll - I'm perverse that way.
Got to be the 84 version.
Got to be the 84 version.
Posted: 08 Nov 2003, 20:46
first one I heard was on the CNT compilation so I guess that would be 82, much more manic than the later one
Posted: 08 Nov 2003, 21:19
I do ...Thrash Harry wrote: You don't understand the question?
but I accidentically forgot to mention I preferred the 84 version ...
I just can't explain why.
Exsqueeze me ...
Posted: 08 Nov 2003, 21:25
[quote="13Vision13]Exsqueeze me ...[/quote]
Well alright!
Well alright!
Posted: 08 Nov 2003, 21:53
Yup.'84 version for me as well 
Posted: 09 Nov 2003, 00:11
82
the angriest song i've ever heard..
the 84 version is too tinny, but the 82 recording rocks like a motherf**ker.
the angriest song i've ever heard..
the 84 version is too tinny, but the 82 recording rocks like a motherf**ker.
Posted: 09 Nov 2003, 07:00
84
I'm just annoyed I couldn't get to choose the demo, instrumental or alternative lyrics versions.
I'm just annoyed I couldn't get to choose the demo, instrumental or alternative lyrics versions.
Posted: 09 Nov 2003, 08:37
82 cause the end of the 84 version ending on the D chord just sucks.
I have no idea why this bothers me so much, but it does.
I have no idea why this bothers me so much, but it does.
Posted: 09 Nov 2003, 11:17
OK QB. Am I stupid or can I only see the results when I'm not logged in?
Posted: 09 Nov 2003, 11:38
OK. So I hadn't voted yet. I knew that.
Posted: 09 Nov 2003, 18:06
82 because it is that original one.
Posted: 09 Nov 2003, 18:41
Gotta be 82, it goes so well with Adrenochrome......
Posted: 09 Nov 2003, 22:10
The 84 version is 24 track - the 82 version is 8 track - I much prefer the 84 version - a much "bigger" sound - and its almost 20 years old! 
Posted: 09 Nov 2003, 22:34
It totally kicks live. The studio versions can't touch it. Hope they bring it back on the next tour.
Posted: 09 Nov 2003, 22:54
Time passes Mr. The Goth, somethings remain
Posted: 09 Nov 2003, 22:59
84 - bigger, harder.
Ooh Matron.
Ooh Matron.
Posted: 09 Nov 2003, 23:00
@ Red Sunsets - Time does Pass - Something does Remain - Unlike my Hair!Red Sunsets wrote:Time passes Mr. The Goth, somethings remain
Posted: 09 Nov 2003, 23:09
Yep <sigh>AndyTheGoth wrote:@ Red Sunsets - Time does Pass - Something does Remain - Unlike my Hair!Red Sunsets wrote:Time passes Mr. The Goth, somethings remain
Posted: 09 Nov 2003, 23:45
...your hair and my memoryAndyTheGoth wrote:@ Red Sunsets - Time does Pass - Something does Remain - Unlike my Hair!Red Sunsets wrote:Time passes Mr. The Goth, somethings remain
Posted: 10 Nov 2003, 11:39
82 for the mad energy and Von's voice sounding weird on it. OK, I buy the arguments about the 84 version sounding bigger and all, but it lacks the spark (pun intended).
Posted: 10 Nov 2003, 15:11
Hey, this one is interesting. I have a real soft spot for 84. As a spotty teenager, just getting into the Sisters, Body and Soul was the first Sisters 12" I ever bought, and I can still smell the amazing smell, and smell the crackly crackle. I really like the cover. I never much liked Body and Soul, or Train for that matter (though in other mixes, and live, it kicks). But Afterhours and the rerecorded Body Electric were like nothing I had heard before. I think I was 17. It was manna from heaven. Therefore I must cast my vote accordingly.
Posted: 13 Nov 2003, 00:13
Well that's that argument won then. 84 it is. Well done my team. Another victory for the first-past-the-post two-party system.