Heartland

Does anyone actually have it?

Does anyone know anyone who actually has it?

What would one have to part with in order to obtain a copy?

Why won't some fucker just weed it?

markfiend wrote:Does anyone actually have it?

yes, but not me

markfiend wrote: Does anyone know anyone who actually has it?

Only Uncle Sister has admitted to owning it

markfiend wrote: What would one have to part with in order to obtain a copy?

I guess an arm and a leg is a good start

markfiend wrote: Why won't some fucker just weed it?

that one i can't answer

just robin & pib as far as i know

and just where is pib these days?

markfiend wrote:Does anyone actually have it?

Does anyone know anyone who actually has it?

What would one have to part with in order to obtain a copy?

Why won't some fucker just weed it?

Is that the Vega version? Has anyone actually heard it, or is its existence just a rumour?

Is that the Vega version? Has anyone actually heard it, or is its existence just a rumour?[/quote]

Well I guess that the above posts clear up it's existence

i thought he meant the james ray vocals version?

i think those traders are gonna keep this one to themselves

Quiff Boy wrote:just robin & pib as far as i know

and just where is pib these days?

as far as I know he doesn't have it, but knew someone who did.
he's on a well deserved holiday.

there are three vocals, Von, James Ray and Vega. That's what Robin posted on Dominion back in the day...

No for sure only Robin got it, never copied
never trust to who claim to have it, lies

Anyone owning the instrumental version of "some kind..

hallucienate wrote:
there are three vocals, Von, James Ray and Vega.

I'd like to hear the James Ray and Vega versions. too. At least to hear...
Maybe we should ask the Peruvian Goth next time

taylor wrote:No for sure only Robin got it, never copied
never trust to who claim to have it, lies

I came across another name of someone who had it (supposedly). He never replied to inquiries about it, though. Should I try to hunt down his name?

Martin

Shall I buy Mr Ray more newcastle Brown Ale then ?

allfear wrote:Shall I buy Mr Ray more newcastle Brown Ale then ?

Worth a try but I doubt he has a copy.

I've heard people talk about this tape. They never have a copy themself but know someone who does. It's always that they're no longer in touch with the person and don't know where they are now, or the other person is an awkward sh!t and won't copy it for anybody.

So does it actually exist? Or is it a joke that got out of hand?

I'm sure it exists.

Dan wrote:

allfear wrote:Shall I buy Mr Ray more newcastle Brown Ale then ?

Worth a try but I doubt he has a copy.

I've heard people talk about this tape. They never have a copy themself but know someone who does. It's always that they're no longer in touch with the person and don't know where they are now, or the other person is an awkward sh!t and won't copy it for anybody.

I guess that I am in the friend-of-a-friend type of scenario which Dan describes. Someone once posted on the dominion listserv a question about a tape which he had. It seemed legitimate to me, but maybe he was just playing games with the list. He never replied to my emails (he probably got a few emails from list memebers), so I can not offer any more details. I may still have his email address or original post, but it is from my old account which I can not access as easily at the moment. It may be in the dominion archives if anyone wants to look through it. I am guessing that it is from 2000 or so. Yeah, not much to go on there, but that is the background of this source. Run with it or consider it a red herring as you see fit.

I also have never seen/heard Robin's copy or been able to get a copy out of him , but I am under the impression that he indeed has a copy. (By the way, I have found dealing with Robin pleasant.) Again, take the value of the statement with as much or little authority as you want.

I at least believe that a recording does exist. Maybe Robin or someone else can confirm that at least.

Martin

Robin described his copy of it on Dominion a good few years back, and there is no reason to doubt him.

Right, consider me convinced it exists

But isn't it frustrating that we can'r get at it!

i dont think robin would weed it. anyone who labels their sales on ebay as 'from the infamous uncle sister collection' doesnt sound like someone whos gonna weed out probably the rarest sisters recording around

Maybe one day we'll see it on ebay for 300 pounds

there isn't any dubts that it exist
Robin got it directly from Andrew Pinnel and AP got directly from JR
there arent any copies around. I had saw a pic of it and remember that got hanwritten titles from Eldo or JR. dont remember exactly who wrote them

also saw the original demo tape (later weeding as K.G) that had also an
handritten cover by eldo in pens.

out of interest you know Mr Ray has a pre whitby warm up gig in london on the 24th oct dony you?

Matt

allfear wrote:out of interest you know Mr Ray has a pre whitby warm up gig in london on the 24th oct dony you?

Matt

gosh, is there a support band?

Well actually I know one band who was asked to do it, unfortunatally the singers wife is having their 2nd Kiddy 2 days before

Matt

hallucienate wrote:

Quiff Boy wrote:just robin & pib as far as i know

and just where is pib these days?

as far as I know he doesn't have it, but knew someone who did.
he's on a well deserved holiday.

there are three vocals, Von, James Ray and Vega. That's what Robin posted on Dominion back in the day...

1. correct

2. correct: just back

3. correct

i did finally get the whole story, but it took ages and ages and i promised not to tell (inner circle stuff). i'll confirm there there are two versions recorded at different sessions, one is even rarer then the other because it was destroyed

doubt robin has both versions:

choose wisely - jesus was a carpenter