Page 1 of 1

I Suppose This Means I'm Mortal, Too

Posted: 14 Jun 2005, 18:55
by CorpPunk
I've been approaching old uni professors of mine about recommendations for grad school lately (that's another story).

Yesterday I got a letter from my favorite English professor saying it was great to hear from me and he'd love to write me a recommendation, but that he's had a stroke and probably isn't the best choice. His writing isn't what it used to be, he wrote, and he "sometimes has trouble with complex sentences." This, from one of the foremost American Lit. scholars in the world, a man who used to enter Middle English pronunciation competitions for the fun of it (and win, too).

Apparently I've gone soft in my old age--I find this terribly upsetting. I think "devastating" is a more accurate word. Would it be insensitive to send him a book I had a hand in, that relates to his former research (but is not an academic book)? It's the only thing I can think of to express my gratitude for his kindnesses to me in the past, but I can see how it might be...well, insensitive.

Re: I Suppose This Means I'm Mortal, Too

Posted: 14 Jun 2005, 19:01
by Delilah
CorpPunk wrote:
Apparently I've gone soft in my old age--I find this terribly upsetting. I think "devastating" is a more accurate word. Would it be insensitive to send him a book I had a hand in, that relates to his former research (but is not an academic book)? It's the only thing I can think of to express my gratitude for his kindnesses to me in the past, but I can see how it might be...well, insensitive.
Go for it! I'm sure it will make him very proud! :D

Re: I Suppose This Means I'm Mortal, Too

Posted: 14 Jun 2005, 21:09
by smiscandlon
Delilah wrote:
CorpPunk wrote:
Apparently I've gone soft in my old age--I find this terribly upsetting. I think "devastating" is a more accurate word. Would it be insensitive to send him a book I had a hand in, that relates to his former research (but is not an academic book)? It's the only thing I can think of to express my gratitude for his kindnesses to me in the past, but I can see how it might be...well, insensitive.
Go for it! I'm sure it will make him very proud! :D
I agree with D.

Good teachers thrive on the accomplishments of their students.

Posted: 14 Jun 2005, 21:25
by Black Alice
I think so too - he answered you and only said that some of his faculties were impaired so he'll still be able to appreciate the gesture........

...........go for it :D - you'll only dwell on it if you don't

Posted: 15 Jun 2005, 10:17
by andymackem
I would. It's a nice gesture, and not obviously pitying.

Softie :wink:

Posted: 15 Jun 2005, 14:45
by CorpPunk
andymackem wrote:Softie :wink:
Tell me about it. It must be hormones or something. I'm going to go watch an instant coffee commericial and cry myself to sleep now.

I hate myself.

Posted: 15 Jun 2005, 15:31
by andymackem
It's when you start laughing at episodes of Will and Grace that you know it's all coming to an end.

I find listening to My Dying Bride puts me back on course.