I Will Call You has been destroyed. In my opinion.
Thanks for the vids though.
"Great" sure is some very positive thinking.Purple Light wrote: ↑05 Aug 2024, 23:06 Andrew sounds great to me.
I Will Call You has been destroyed. In my opinion.
Thanks for the vids though.![]()
Tend to agree. I liked its old chugging drive. Too much twiddle in this one.
Thirded. I hadn't got round to giving that one a listen, destroyed is perhaps too strong a word for me but it's impact as a psychedelic stomper has definitely been reduced somewhat. That said, they'd already shortened the supergroovy psychedelic break in the middle, ie the bit everyone used to cheer like fk about in its original form. Neverind eh. If they're removing the chug out of everything then now is the perfect time to reintroduce the sublime beyond words Black Sail into the setlist. But then I still operate on the mentality of thinking the perfect Sisters setlist would currently contain precisely no songs that were ever recorded and released officially. Except Susanne, that can stay.
Yeah, I'm not sure I'd go so far as "destroyed" either but I do think that it's current form departs from most of the things that made it a favourite for me. I do respect the overall impetus though, as the song should transform to reflect the band, so I'm not complaining as such. There's also something so so Sisters about inverting the arrangement in this particular fashion, ie Ben's high end is now the lower end, Dylan's deep chug-a-lug replaced by Kai's shimmery bits, but what can i say? Just doesn't resonate with me like this.Planet Dave wrote: ↑06 Aug 2024, 14:55Thirded. I hadn't got round to giving that one a listen, destroyed is perhaps too strong a word for me but it's impact as a psychedelic stomper has definitely been reduced somewhat. That said, they'd already shortened the supergroovy psychedelic break in the middle, ie the bit everyone used to cheer like fk about in its original form. Neverind eh. If they're removing the chug out of everything then now is the perfect time to reintroduce the sublime beyond words Black Sail into the setlist. But then I still operate on the mentality of thinking the perfect Sisters setlist would currently contain precisely no songs that were ever recorded and released officially. Except Susanne, that can stay.
Oof, yeah, that's kinda slaughtered by now. Your first sentence nails it. It was a stomper. Now it's a bit banal and bland. For me, Show Me took the same route after its premiere at Trix back then.Fallon wrote: ↑06 Aug 2024, 16:10
Yeah, I'm not sure I'd go so far as "destroyed" either but I do think that it's current form departs from most of the things that made it a favourite for me. I do respect the overall impetus though, as the song should transform to reflect the band, so I'm not complaining as such. There's also something so so Sisters about inverting the arrangement in this particular fashion, ie Ben's high end is now the lower end, Dylan's deep chug-a-lug replaced by Kai's shimmery bits, but what can i say? Just doesn't resonate with me like this.
Can't help wondering if I might connect with it a little more if they make some more extensive adjustments to the backing track though. That first post-chorus break doesn't really feel like it's part of the same song anymore, not sure if anyone else finds it a little awkward now.
Maybe there's just a bit more work needed to bring the arrangement to life properly.