Nope. I think you don't know what a producer & top class engineer actually contributes to a record, otherwise why have them - it's not just twiddling with knobs, most bands are capable of twiddling their own knobs.nodubmanshouts wrote:You are confusing production and engineering with writing.
Hussey would like to work again with Eldritch
-
moses
- Utterly Bastard Groovy Amphetamine Filth
- Posts: 564
- Joined: 03 Sep 2008, 12:38
- Location: On The Darkside Of The Tune
The ceremony of innocence is drowned;
The best lack all conviction, while the worst
Are full of passionate intensity
The best lack all conviction, while the worst
Are full of passionate intensity
-
nodubmanshouts
- Utterly Bastard Groovy Amphetamine Filth
- Posts: 557
- Joined: 19 Oct 2003, 06:50
- Location: California
Yes, I do know.
However, in most cases, chopping up verses, re-arranging choruses, adding arrangements, creating a sound, and getting the best out of the musicians doesn't qualify as a writing credit...
However, in most cases, chopping up verses, re-arranging choruses, adding arrangements, creating a sound, and getting the best out of the musicians doesn't qualify as a writing credit...
-
moses
- Utterly Bastard Groovy Amphetamine Filth
- Posts: 564
- Joined: 03 Sep 2008, 12:38
- Location: On The Darkside Of The Tune
I would say it does and so do U2 as they have given Brian Eno and Daniel Lanois writing credit on their new album.nodubmanshouts wrote:Yes, I do know.
However, in most cases, chopping up verses, re-arranging choruses, adding arrangements, creating a sound, and getting the best out of the musicians doesn't qualify as a writing credit...
Anyway it's neither here no there, people are dying through starvation all over the world and writing or producing music doesn't change that.
The ceremony of innocence is drowned;
The best lack all conviction, while the worst
Are full of passionate intensity
The best lack all conviction, while the worst
Are full of passionate intensity
Depends. Steve Albini would likewise downplay the role of the "producer", whereas New Order have commonly given external producers (aside from Hannett) a co-writing credit.nodubmanshouts wrote:Yes, I do know.
However, in most cases, chopping up verses, re-arranging choruses, adding arrangements, creating a sound, and getting the best out of the musicians doesn't qualify as a writing credit...
If I told them once, I told them a hundred times to put 'Spinal Tap' first and 'Puppet Show' last.
-
Syberberg
- Utterly Bastard Groovy Amphetamine Filth
- Posts: 959
- Joined: 17 Feb 2006, 05:46
- Location: The People's Republic of West Yorkshire.
If a producer has done more than the usual by actually being included into the writing process, not just the arranging side of things, then it's up to the band/artist in question to decide whether they deserve a writing credit or not (which also means a potential share of royalties). Eldritch did that with Jim Steinman, giving him a writing credit on the lyrics for More.mh wrote:Depends. Steve Albini would likewise downplay the role of the "producer", whereas New Order have commonly given external producers (aside from Hannett) a co-writing credit.nodubmanshouts wrote:Yes, I do know.
However, in most cases, chopping up verses, re-arranging choruses, adding arrangements, creating a sound, and getting the best out of the musicians doesn't qualify as a writing credit...
I don't necessarily agree with everything I think.
-
eastmidswhizzkid
- Faster Than The Light Of Speed
- Posts: 9774
- Joined: 24 Mar 2005, 00:01
- Location: WhizzWorld
- Contact:
no need, i'm sure you own the record. it's there in black and white:moses wrote:eastmidswhizzkid wrote:floodland was written -musically and lyrically- entirely by one man.
No Jim Steinman or Larry Alexander? Show me the label!
Floodand...Written by Andrew Eldritch.
the production credits include those you mention but production is part of the studio process; the songs were written before these people were brought in.
Well I was handsome and I was strong
And I knew the words to every song.
"Did my singing please you?"
"No! The words you sang were wrong!"
And I knew the words to every song.
"Did my singing please you?"
"No! The words you sang were wrong!"
-
Maisey
- Slight Overbomber
- Posts: 1870
- Joined: 28 Jun 2006, 20:19
- Location: Moving like a Parallelogram
Production does an aweful lot for the sound of a record, but fundamentally its the songwriting that makes it. Thus, if you like Floodland, you have to credit Eldo as a songwriter.
For me, a nice way to single out the difference between production and song writing is to listen to a demo version of a song and then compare it to the final version.
For me, a nice way to single out the difference between production and song writing is to listen to a demo version of a song and then compare it to the final version.
Nationalise the f**king lot.
-
moses
- Utterly Bastard Groovy Amphetamine Filth
- Posts: 564
- Joined: 03 Sep 2008, 12:38
- Location: On The Darkside Of The Tune
On top of their working fee producers involved in the writing & arranging of tracks more often than not receive a 'points' percentage per record sold - akin to mechanical royalties - in leu of a writing credit to uphold the 'artists' credibility.Syberberg wrote: If a producer has done more than the usual by actually being included into the writing process, not just the arranging side of things, then it's up to the band/artist in question to decide whether they deserve a writing credit or not (which also means a potential share of royalties). Eldritch did that with Jim Steinman, giving him a writing credit on the lyrics for More.
The ceremony of innocence is drowned;
The best lack all conviction, while the worst
Are full of passionate intensity
The best lack all conviction, while the worst
Are full of passionate intensity
-
nodubmanshouts
- Utterly Bastard Groovy Amphetamine Filth
- Posts: 557
- Joined: 19 Oct 2003, 06:50
- Location: California
What Syberberg said.
As I said.... "in most cases". There are exceptions. Most U2 albums are not exceptions.
As I said.... "in most cases". There are exceptions. Most U2 albums are not exceptions.
moses, I suggest you learn to debate and state an argument, rather than use pathetic cop-outs.Anyway it's neither here no there, people are dying through starvation all over the world and writing or producing music doesn't change that.
-
moses
- Utterly Bastard Groovy Amphetamine Filth
- Posts: 564
- Joined: 03 Sep 2008, 12:38
- Location: On The Darkside Of The Tune
It wasnt a 'cop-out', pathetic or notnodubmanshouts wrote:
moses, I suggest you learn to debate and state an argument, rather than use pathetic cop-outs.
, it was a statement of fact in order to express my boredom with a pointless debate that has nothing to do with the likelyhood of Hussey ever working again with Eldritch. And as I have been fortunate enough over my life (through my dad) to have experienced at firrst hand the studio proccess of creating music at the very height of the profession and the politics and relationships therein, I know the score.
The ceremony of innocence is drowned;
The best lack all conviction, while the worst
Are full of passionate intensity
The best lack all conviction, while the worst
Are full of passionate intensity
Check out the Hussey interview done by Janice Long on Disc 2 from the recently released The m*****n "Live&Last" DoCD, where Wayne says he is not opposed to working again with Eldritch, although he may mean something like doing only some nostalgia gig together or whatever.
"well never say never, but I can't personally see it"; "if I get the call..."
Andrew Eldritch will not agree.
"well never say never, but I can't personally see it"; "if I get the call..."
Andrew Eldritch will not agree.
-
eastmidswhizzkid
- Faster Than The Light Of Speed
- Posts: 9774
- Joined: 24 Mar 2005, 00:01
- Location: WhizzWorld
- Contact:
if you think this debate is pointless you're going be unhappy here -we do "pointless" debates to death.moses wrote: it was a statement of fact in order to express my boredom with a pointless debate
Well I was handsome and I was strong
And I knew the words to every song.
"Did my singing please you?"
"No! The words you sang were wrong!"
And I knew the words to every song.
"Did my singing please you?"
"No! The words you sang were wrong!"
-
sultan2075
- Overbomber
- Posts: 2310
- Joined: 04 Mar 2005, 19:17
- Location: Washington, D. C.
- Contact:
Just wait until that new album comes out!eastmidswhizzkid wrote:if you think this debate is pointless you're going be unhappy here -we do "pointless" debates to death.moses wrote: it was a statement of fact in order to express my boredom with a pointless debate
--
The most successful tyranny is not the one that uses force to assure uniformity but the one that removes the awareness of other possibilities, that makes it seem inconceivable that other ways are viable, that removes the sense that there is an outside.
The most successful tyranny is not the one that uses force to assure uniformity but the one that removes the awareness of other possibilities, that makes it seem inconceivable that other ways are viable, that removes the sense that there is an outside.
I am new here so forgive me if I am incorrect or repeating anything but......
The lyrics to More had to be pretty much re written by JS due to the original ones being open to liable action about whom they were written........
The only reason that Hussey would want to work again with AE is for money reasons?
Personally I hated The M*****n. At the time I was into the sisters I was about 15/16 when TM brought out Wasteland. I knew it was Hussey from the Sisters - but I didnt know about the feud or anything.
All I can remember thinking is OMG this is awful.
It was like Eurasure does The Sisters of Mercy. Terrible. Terrible. Yes, a lot of people liked it but I was NOT one of them!
He may be a good guitarist but the records that were done when he was with the Sisters were clearly 99% the others 1% Husseys influence.
And can any true Sisters fan really forgive him for trying to steal the name? and as for playing their songs live - WTF?
To continue the Eurasue theme (as thats all I can think of now as a similie) that is like Vince Clark leaving Depeche Mode, calling his new band Depeche and continuing to play Just Cant Get Enough!
The lyrics to More had to be pretty much re written by JS due to the original ones being open to liable action about whom they were written........
The only reason that Hussey would want to work again with AE is for money reasons?
Personally I hated The M*****n. At the time I was into the sisters I was about 15/16 when TM brought out Wasteland. I knew it was Hussey from the Sisters - but I didnt know about the feud or anything.
All I can remember thinking is OMG this is awful.
It was like Eurasure does The Sisters of Mercy. Terrible. Terrible. Yes, a lot of people liked it but I was NOT one of them!
He may be a good guitarist but the records that were done when he was with the Sisters were clearly 99% the others 1% Husseys influence.
And can any true Sisters fan really forgive him for trying to steal the name? and as for playing their songs live - WTF?
To continue the Eurasue theme (as thats all I can think of now as a similie) that is like Vince Clark leaving Depeche Mode, calling his new band Depeche and continuing to play Just Cant Get Enough!
-
Quiff Boy
- Herr Administrator
- Posts: 16762
- Joined: 25 Jan 2002, 00:00
- Location: Lurking and fixing
- Contact:
then you will have to post a whole lot more for thatDebi wrote:Because I quite like Utterly Bastard Groovy!!
standard ranks: (taken from the statistics page - http://www.myheartland.co.uk/statistics.php)
there are also a few people who have custom/personal 'ranks' but you'd have to be a regular to warrant one of thoseI wrote:Road Kill 0 - 99 posts
Amphetamine Filth 100 - 249 posts
Gonzoid Amphetamine Filth 250 - 499 posts
Utterly Bastard Groovy Amphetamine Filth 500 - 999 posts
Slight Overbomber 1000 - 1999 posts
Overbomber 2000 - 4999 posts
Underneath the Rock 5000 - 7499 posts
Above the Chemist 7500 - 14999 posts
Intellectual Love God 15000 - 14999 posts
What’s the difference between a buffalo and a bison?
-
markfiend
- goriller of form 3b
- Posts: 21181
- Joined: 11 Nov 2003, 10:55
- Location: st custards
- Contact:
Shurely shome mishtake?Intellectual Love God 15000 - 14999 posts
The fundamental cause of the trouble is that in the modern world the stupid are cocksure while the intelligent are full of doubt.
—Bertrand Russell
—Bertrand Russell
-
Quiff Boy
- Herr Administrator
- Posts: 16762
- Joined: 25 Jan 2002, 00:00
- Location: Lurking and fixing
- Contact:
well spotted!
its quirk of the way the stats page is displaying the ranks... there's actually no upper ceiling on that rank, thus:
Intellectual Love God 15000+
strange
its quirk of the way the stats page is displaying the ranks... there's actually no upper ceiling on that rank, thus:
Intellectual Love God 15000+
strange
What’s the difference between a buffalo and a bison?
-
Quiff Boy
- Herr Administrator
- Posts: 16762
- Joined: 25 Jan 2002, 00:00
- Location: Lurking and fixing
- Contact:
ooooh, controversialDebi wrote:"Intellectual Love God 15000 - 14999 posts"
yeah - whats the point in being intellectual or a love God if you've got no spare time cos you are glued to a forum!!!
What’s the difference between a buffalo and a bison?